Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Sites | Writers | Advertise | My Orble | Login

TV, Radio or Computer?

July 6th 2008 23:01
TV, radio or computer - which has been the most influential on society?
As a result of nothing in particular - conversation turned to discussion which then turned to debate amongst a group of friends over weekend with regards to which of the three modern mediums - televisoin, radio or computers has had the most profound influence on society.


Of course - a bit like a dog chasing its own tail - all three have their virtues and all three have played a huge role in shaping today's world.

But which (in your opinon) has been THE most influential?

Would love to add your reasoning to our weekend debate - err - discussion.
142
Vote
Shared on


   
Subscribe to this blog 


Just this blog This blog and DailyOrble (recommended)

   

   


Comments
20 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by Chris Champion

July 7th 2008 01:01
As you say, all three have their virtues, but only one has its viruses

One thought is that television encompassed the capabilities of radio, and computers encompass the capabilities of television, making computers the most powerful medium.

But have people generally been influenced by using a computer the same way that early radio listeners, awed by the magical new medium, were influenced by the world of opinion suddenly available to them?

Another crucial question is this: was it red wine or beer that accompanied your weekend discussion

Regards,
Chris

Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 01:24
Salient points

The net (and by stealth the computer) has put people in touch with people like no other method of communication has done before - but I'm sure similar was said of how TV bridged the divide and radio brought news of the world to our liviving rooms.

It's a toughie.

BTW - it was a liberal smattering of Red - with a guest appearance of a couple of fruity whites.

Comment by Damo

July 7th 2008 02:21
Television drug of a nation (something, something, something) and breeding radiation.

God bless television. Keep the programming pure...

Don't adjust you set, There is nothing wrong with it....

On Big Brother tonight which self obsessed television hopeful will have there dream dash in front of your eyes?

Call now and you will get this et of steak knives as well....

I am waiting for your call... Girls gone wild...

Tonight on the Biggest loser we will reject claims that it nothing more than fatsploitation. Pork Pig here will give the talk.

Australia's Top Model. Because we say so and she does not know better.

Australian Idol. Yes we can manufacture a star so you better be thankful. Otherwise we will bring back Don Lane.

Tonight on Today Tonight we found another person in Queensland ripping of old people who should know better. We also have a story about a weight lose pill that despite its paid endorsement does work.

Oh my Gawd they killed Kenny, And now here is another fart joke.

Actually the Bottom line is:
I only like Top Gear. Mythbusters, Death Note and the occasional Dr Who.

Death Note is on tonight and it is really good.

Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 02:33
Damo

Wonder why they run all that?

Will say Mythbusters is outstanding - can't wait for one of the commercial stations to pick it up - denude it - give it an a couple of celebrity psudo scientific geeks and have all equipment used supplied by Bunnings . . .

Cheers champ

Comment by Cibbuano

July 7th 2008 02:39
I think television HAS had the most impact, but computers will prove to eclipse them. After all, we're working towards artificial intelligence, right?


Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 02:43
Cib

One could argue that there's already too much artificial intelltigence fronting television programmes now

Cheers buddy

Comment by Chris Champion

July 7th 2008 03:00
One could argue that there's already too much artificial intelltigence fronting television programmes now

One could argue that the entire Nine Network news presentation philosophy resembles that remark.

Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 03:09
. . . let's not go down that path too far.

Besides we do have Big Brother, Dancing with the Stars, Today Tonight et al.

Nice to know that each station like to dumb down

Comment by Lara M

July 7th 2008 10:38
I think it's the TV -- it's amazing how many people can't live without it... Though I think the computer isn't far behind, but I think TV will always be up there. Mmmm...

Comment by Morgan Bell

July 7th 2008 13:55
hmmm probably the TV . . .

although if i had all 3 infront of me and i could only turn one on i would definately choose the computer!

Comment by Mountain Fog

July 7th 2008 14:21
I agree with Cibby's purview, adding one stage;

Radio started the communication/information/ind octrination revolution...

TV finessed it and made it into a crass art form with dangerously subtle abilities of persuasion

and finally computers will outclipse them all, just before we find out the Mayans were right, and the world ends on December the 22nd 2012, at 11-11am!!!

Lets throw a HUGE Orbellean party on the 21st of December 2012!!!!?? No pooters, just ipods maybe!!

cheers and love that old TV in the picture MNG!

fog

Comment by Mrs M

July 7th 2008 14:58
By computers I assume you mean internet?

Both radio and television only requires a passive response while the internet is the opposite. Case in point, this post.

Love & stuff
Mrs M

Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 22:52
Lara M

It's a toughie isn't it? Each is a product of the ages. Have to admit to being a real fence sitter on this one.

Great to see you.

MNG

Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 22:54
Morgan

Corny innuendo aside - I don't know which (if given the choice) I would turn on if only afford one . . . I guess if I was on a desert island I probably go with TV - but then again . . . .

Cheers

Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 22:56
Fog

Damn!

And I'd pre-tuned the box for the Peanuts Christmas special on the 23rd.

Bloody Mayans . . .



Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 7th 2008 23:00
Mrs M

Good point.

Though through the whole 'vote for your favourite housemate', 'vote via SMS for your favourite song', 'call us and let us know your thoughts on . . .' et al - I guess all mediums see value (and money) in public interaction.

Stay well

Comment by KylieW

July 8th 2008 01:59
I think it's definitely television. But I wouldn't be surprised to see computers overtake that one day (I'm of the MTv generation, my young cousins are more the You Tube generation......who knows what my kids will be!)

Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 8th 2008 03:01
Scary stuff really.

When I see the technology my kids are using - it makes me feel very antiquated.

Ouch.

Stay well

Comment by Miswanderlust

July 9th 2008 02:51
I can’t think of a more powerful social media channel than the TV broadcasting. Sure, there are millions of people on MySpace, Facebook. Even more that watch video’s on YouTube or comment on blogs. But a major TV event can bring hundreds of millions of people to a screen the size of some 30 inches or so. In most cases it’s the major sports events such as the Olympic games,. And these people engage with the screen. They scream, cheer, curse, cry, hug, and probably show every emotion possible during a match. Can we socialize like that in the virtual world? Just asking...

Have really enjoyed the comments.
Cheers!

Mis


Comment by Mr Nice Guy

July 9th 2008 03:27
Hey Mis

Boy - and I thought I would glean a more concise picture of which way people were leaning . . . think I'm getting even more splinters from that uneasy fence sitting.

Everything you say is of course - 'right on the money' to use racing parlance.

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Notify extra people about this comment
Is this a private comment?
List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this comment


One per line max of 30

List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this private comment thread. Only the people in this list will be able to see or reply to your comment.


One per line max of 30

Your Name
(for the email going out to the above list, it can be different to your Orble Tag)
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
9 Posts
12 Posts
11 Posts
282 Posts dating from June 2007
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

Mr Nice Guy's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Moderated by Mr Nice Guy
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]